pprof
pprof
is a cpu profiler that can be easily integrated into a rust program.
Usage
First, get a guard to start profiling. Profiling will continue until this guard was dropped.
let guard = default.frequency.blocklist.build.unwrap;
During the profiling time, you can get a report with the guard.
if let Ok = guard.report.build ;
Debug
was implemented for Report
. It will print a human-readable stack counter report. Here is an example:
FRAME: backtrace::backtrace::trace::h3e91a3123a3049a5 -> FRAME: pprof::profiler::perf_signal_handler::h7b995c4ab2e66493 -> FRAME: Unknown -> FRAME: prime_number::is_prime_number::h70653a2633b88023 -> FRAME: prime_number::main::h47f1058543990c8b -> FRAME: std::rt::lang_start::{{closure}}::h4262e250f8024b06 -> FRAME: std::rt::lang_start_internal::{{closure}}::h812f70926ebbddd0 -> std::panicking::try::do_call::h3210e2ce6a68897b -> FRAME: __rust_maybe_catch_panic -> FRAME: std::panicking::try::h28c2e2ec1c3871ce -> std::panic::catch_unwind::h05e542185e35aabf -> std::rt::lang_start_internal::hd7efcfd33686f472 -> FRAME: main -> FRAME: __libc_start_main -> FRAME: _start -> FRAME: Unknown -> THREAD: prime_number 1217
FRAME: backtrace::backtrace::trace::h3e91a3123a3049a5 -> FRAME: pprof::profiler::perf_signal_handler::h7b995c4ab2e66493 -> FRAME: Unknown -> FRAME: alloc::alloc::box_free::h82cea48ed688e081 -> FRAME: prime_number::main::h47f1058543990c8b -> FRAME: std::rt::lang_start::{{closure}}::h4262e250f8024b06 -> FRAME: std::rt::lang_start_internal::{{closure}}::h812f70926ebbddd0 -> std::panicking::try::do_call::h3210e2ce6a68897b -> FRAME: __rust_maybe_catch_panic -> FRAME: std::panicking::try::h28c2e2ec1c3871ce -> std::panic::catch_unwind::h05e542185e35aabf -> std::rt::lang_start_internal::hd7efcfd33686f472 -> FRAME: main -> FRAME: __libc_start_main -> FRAME: _start -> FRAME: Unknown -> THREAD: prime_number 1
FRAME: backtrace::backtrace::trace::h3e91a3123a3049a5 -> FRAME: pprof::profiler::perf_signal_handler::h7b995c4ab2e66493 -> FRAME: Unknown -> FRAME: prime_number::main::h47f1058543990c8b -> FRAME: std::rt::lang_start::{{closure}}::h4262e250f8024b06 -> FRAME: std::rt::lang_start_internal::{{closure}}::h812f70926ebbddd0 -> std::panicking::try::do_call::h3210e2ce6a68897b -> FRAME: __rust_maybe_catch_panic -> FRAME: std::panicking::try::h28c2e2ec1c3871ce -> std::panic::catch_unwind::h05e542185e35aabf -> std::rt::lang_start_internal::hd7efcfd33686f472 -> FRAME: main -> FRAME: __libc_start_main -> FRAME: _start -> FRAME: Unknown -> THREAD: prime_number 1
Features
cpp
enables the cpp demangle.flamegraph
enables the flamegraph report format.prost-codec
enables the pprof protobuf report format throughprost
.protobuf-codec
enables the pprof protobuf report format throughprotobuf
crate.frame-pointer
gets the backtrace through frame pointer. only available for nightly
Flamegraph
= { = "0.14", = ["flamegraph"] }
If flamegraph
feature is enabled, you can generate flamegraph from the report. Report
struct has a method flamegraph
which can generate flamegraph and write it into a Write
.
if let Ok = guard.report.build ;
Additionally, custom flamegraph options can be specified.
if let Ok = guard.report.build ;
Here is an example of generated flamegraph:
Frame Post Processor
Before the report was generated, frame_post_processor
was provided as an interface to modify raw statistic data. If you want to group several symbols/thread or demangle for some symbols, this feature will benefit you.
For example:
if let Ok = guard.frames_post_processor.report.build
Use with pprof
With protobuf
feature enabled, pprof-rs
can also output profile.proto
format.
match guard.report.build ;
Then you can use pprof
command with profile.pb
. For example:
~/go/bin/pprof -svg profile.pb
Then pprof
will generate a svg file according to the profile.
Integrate with criterion
With criterion
feature enabled, a criterion custom profiler is provided in pprof-rs
.
use ;
criterion_group!
criterion_main!;
After running the benchmark, you can find the flamegraph at target/criterion/<name-of-benchmark>/profile/flamegraph.svg
. protobuf
output is also available with the Output::Protobuf
option; these end up at target/criterion/<name-of-benchmark>/profile.pb
.
For more details, you can check the examples/criterion.rs
, and the profiling document of criterion
. For a quick start, you can run this example with cargo run --example criterion --release --features="flamegraph criterion" -- --bench --profile-time 5
Why not ...
There have been tons of profilers, why we create a new one? Here we make a comparison between pprof-rs
and other popular profilers to help you choose the best fit one.
gperftools
gperftools
is also an integrated profiler. There is also a wrapper for gperftools
in rust called cpuprofiler
which makes it programmable for a rust program.
Pros
pprof-rs
has a modern build system and can be integrated into a rust program easily while compilinggperftools
statically is buggy.pprof-rs
has a native rust interface whilegperftools
's wrapper is just a wrapper.- Programming with rust guarantees thread safety natively.
Cons
gperftools
is a collection of performance analysis tools which contains cpu profiler, heap profiler...pprof-rs
focuses on cpu profiler now.
perf
perf
is a performance analyzing tool in Linux.
Pros
- You don't need to start another process to perf with
pprof-rs
. pprof-rs
can be easily integrated with rust program which means you don't need to install any other programs.pprof-rs
has a modern programmable interface to hack withpprof-rs
theoretically supports all POSIX systems and can easily support more systems in the future.
Cons
perf
is much more feature-rich thanpprof-rs
.perf
is highly integrated with Linux.
Implementation
When profiling was started, setitimer
system call was used to set up a timer which will send a SIGPROF to this program every constant interval.
When receiving a SIGPROF signal, the signal handler will capture a backtrace and increase the count of it. After a while, the profiler can get every possible backtrace and their count. Finally, we can generate a report with profiler data.
However, the real world is full of thorns. There are many worths of note parts in the implementation.
Backtrace
Unfortunately, there is no 100% robust stack tracing method. Some related researches have been done by gperftools. pprof-rs
uses backtrace-rs
which finally uses libunwind provided by libgcc
WARN: as described in former gperftools documents, libunwind provided by libgcc
is not signal safe.
libgcc's unwind method is not safe to use from signal handlers. One particular cause of deadlock is when profiling tick happens when program is propagating thrown exception.
This can be resolved by adding a blocklist:
let guard = default.frequency.blocklist.build.unwrap;
The vdso
should also be added to the blocklist, because in some distribution (e.g. ubuntu 18.04), the dwarf information in vdso is incorrect.
Frame Pointer
The pprof-rs
also supports unwinding through frame pointer, without the need to use libunwind
. However, the standard library shipped with the rust compiler does not have the correct frame pointer in every function, so you need to use cargo +nightly -Z build-std
to build the standard library from source.
As we cannot get the stack boundaries inside the signal handler, it's also not possible to ensure the safety. If the frame pointer was set to a wrong value, the program will panic.
Signal Safety
Signal safety is hard to guarantee. But it's not that hard.
First, we have to avoid deadlock. When profiler samples or reports, it will get a global lock on the profiler. Particularly, deadlock happenswhen the running program is getting a report from the profiler (which will hold the lock), at the same time, a SIGPROF signal is triggered and the profiler wants to sample (which will also hold the lock). So we don't wait for the lock in signal handler, instead we try_lock
in the signal handler. If the global lock cannot be gotten, the profiler will give up directly.
Then, signal safety POSIX function is quite limited as listed here. The most bothering issue is that we cannot use malloc
in signal handler. So we can only use pre-allocated memory in profiler. The simplest way is write
every sample serially into a file. We optimized it with a fix-sized hashmap that has a fixed number of buckets and every bucket is an array with a fixed number of items. If the hashmap is full, we pop out the item with minimum count and write it into a temporary file.
Unit tests have been added to guarantee there is no malloc
in sample functions.
futex
is also not safe to use in signal handler. So we use a spin lock to avoid usage of futex
.
TODO
- Restore the original SIGPROF handler after stopping the profiler.
Minimum Supported Rust Version
Rust 1.64 or higher.
Minimum supported Rust version can be changed in the future, but it will be done with a minor version bump.